Who Do You Believe? - Season 1

Secrets from the past are revealed as newly married Mark and Charity navigate their rocky relationship. Dangerous accusations, manipulation and control take over, but who is telling the truth? Just as they reach the breaking point, shocking discoveries are made.

Nichelle Nichols was once a Hollywood groundbreaker as the first Black woman to star in a network television show. Today, her struggling health and increasing dementia leave her caught between her son and her new manager in a vicious and public battle for conservatorship. Both are increasingly suspicious over the other's motives, and both claim to have Nichelle's best interest at heart; but who is the real protector and who is the predator?

 

Celeste is a struggling mother of twin teenage girls, fighting to reunite her children after they were split apart in a bitter custody battle. While working as a country club waitress, she meets and marries Steven Beard, a man more than 40 years her senior that is worth millions. The marriage seemingly gives Celeste and her daughters Jennifer and Kristina a brief storybook life that is shattered by a late-night shotgun blast that leaves one of them dead and the others fighting over the truth of what really happened. Does mother know best, or does she have something to hide?
 

The riveting battle between Celeste Beard and her twin teenage daughters continues to unfold in part two of this unbelievable true-crime story. Secret recordings and a shocking confession point suspicion toward Celeste and her best friend's possible involvement. When the walls start closing in on Celeste, her daughters go on the run fearing their own lives could be in danger. With family members now foes, who is to blame for their epic collapse and who is telling the truth?

If you cannot trust your own mother or your own child, who can you trust? After Sandra Garner's husband is murdered in their bed the night of their anniversary, a series of wild alibis and a bizarre 911 call leaves mother and son pointing fingers and questioning whether the other is lying. In a curious case where evidence suddenly materializes and accusations fly, even the police is puzzled, but will you be? With each claiming the other had a motive and the opportunity to pull the trigger, it's up to you to decide.

A rare heirloom passed down within the Ojibwe tribe is confirmed as one of the oldest American flags in history and worth millions. When the flag's keeper dies without naming an heir, a vicious inheritance war breaks out. With family ties, tribal welfare and American history on the line, how far will they go to capture the flag? Amidst betrayal, corruption and lies, who is the rightful owner? It's up to you to decide.

An up-and-coming Detroit neighborhood appears to be a mini oasis providing a new start for members of a tight-knit community, but not everything is what it seems. When outsider Chaz moves in, he quickly finds himself locked in a war with his next-door neighbor Marc. Lines are crossed, threats are made, and egos flare, ultimately leaving one of them lying dead in the street and the other fighting for their life in court. Was it self-defense or murder? In a battle on the block, which side of the fence are you on?

Jordynn Watson's mom goes missing and her grandma Marilyn is gunned down all before she celebrates her eighth birthday. Investigators claim to be doing all they can to find her mother and catch a killer, but their efforts stall and the case goes cold. Jordynn wants answers, but when the case heats back up, she doesn't like the direction Detective Kelly Anderson is heading - straight for her father. Jordynn's convinced he is innocent, but it seems to her the cold-case detective is hellbent on putting him away for life. The battle between the detective and the daughter of the accused climaxes in not one but two murder trials on the gripping season finale.